Amy Devitt
  • Home
  • About
  • CV and Resume
  • Publications
    • Books
    • Articles and Essays
    • Talks, Seminars, Workshops
    • Occasional Pieces
  • Genre-Colored Glasses

Genre-colored glasses

Thoughts on genre, language, grammar, and other
rhetorical and linguistic norms

Hurricanes and US

9/11/2017

0 Comments

 

Or is it Them?

color satellite image of Hurricane Harvey
Hurricane Harvey, European Space Agency, Flickr, (CC BY-SA 2.0)

On this particular day in the US we’re dealing with two devastating events--
  • Hurricanes Harvey, Irma, and too soon Jose
  • the anniversary of September 11
 
Both disastrous events causing lost lives and physical destruction. Both causing shocking trauma and lifelong fears. Both changing how people act in the world, what they trust, how safe they feel.
 
Some say the hurricanes are bringing us together like 9/11 did, reuniting Americans after such a long period of divisiveness politically and socially. But I’m not so sure.
 
I’d have to ignore the fact of economic divides—yes, the hurricanes hit neighborhoods of different economic strata, but the residents differed in their abilities to evacuate and will differ in their abilities to recover financially.
 
And then I’d have to ignore the language used. Writing and speaking about the hurricanes, people express horror and sympathy for what has happened or is happening to “them.” Not “us.” “Them.”
 
After 9/11, even though the murders happened in specific East Coast locations, the terrorism happened to us, to Americans. It was directed at us, so we took it that way.
 
Of course, hurricanes are (mostly) natural events, not political plots, no matter what Rush Limbaugh claims. Harvey didn’t have it in for Americans. Irma isn’t trying to destroy the United States and its people.
 
But when politicians give speeches to rally support and uplift spirits, they haven’t been talking about how much damage the hurricanes are doing to us, the US. When governors or mayors encourage “us” to keep our spirits up or tell us “we” can make it, they explicitly include only the residents of their states. Texas and Florida, not the United States.
 
Yes, in some ways, that focus on the states makes sense. Governors represent their states, so you might expect them to address their own residents first and foremost. Governors have authority only within their state, to make proclamations and send aid. And the hurricanes did cause damage, death, and suffering directly to Texans and Floridians, not to all Americans. 
​
But the governors’ emphasis has been on what makes the residents of their states especially strong, or especially able to deal with hurricanes, or especially resilient and helpful—separate and apart and explicitly not as Americans. It’s not Americans coming together to help each other, to rebuild, to prepare. It’s Texans. It’s Floridians.

I’m certainly not resentful that I was left out of reassuring speeches, even though I’ve watched the events with horror. Luckily I was watching, after all, not experiencing.  But that is true for most residents of Texas, too. They were watching, sometimes from some distance. But the governors have chosen to emphasize the unity of the state, not the United States.
 
The results for Florida are still to come, as I’m writing this, so I’ll be listening to hear how Governor Rick Scott addresses the people afterward. Early on, he tweeted that "FL knows how important it is to be prepared.” Texas Governor Greg Abbott, on Good Morning America, praised not Americans but Texans for their on-site actions: 
"You have to be proud to see the way our fellow Texans have responded," Abbott said, "whether they be the first responders or just neighbors helping neighbors to deal with this overwhelming catastrophe."
Even for actions that everyone in the world could take, Gov. Abbott still referred only to Texans. When he called for a day of prayer, August 31, he called for a day of prayer in Texas alone, calling people of all faiths in Texas, not in America, to pray as "one united people." He can’t declare a day of prayer for all Americans, but he didn’t even invite all Americans to join in.
 
I don’t mean to take anything away from the governors or from the anguish dumped on Texans and Floridians. They have every right to band together as Texans, as Floridians, and to be proud of how they unify to act together.
 
I’m simply pointing out that there are times when we in the United States see ourselves as Americans, and times when we see ourselves as members of smaller communities. Texas. Florida. After 9/11, New Yorkers had a special place of honor for enduring the greatest loss of life. And I’m sure there were speeches at the time encouraging New Yorkers and praising the resilience of New Yorkers. But they were also Americans, and the hit was taken by all Americans.

What does it mean that the hit of the hurricanes is being taken by Texans and Floridians, not Americans?

​If that attack on our shores were being seen as an attack on America, we might all see ourselves as responsible for the recovery. To some extent that’s happening. The federal legislature is planning an increase in funds for the Federal Emergency Management Agency. National relief for Hurricane Harvey has already been promised. And announcers at sporting events everywhere are calling for donations, and people everywhere are donating.
 
For them.
 
If we saw the hurricanes as threats to all of us, not just Texans and Floridians, we could be rallying and fund-raising for our cities, our houses, our infrastructure, not for theirs.
 
If we saw the hurricanes as threats to all of us, not just Texans and Floridians, we could be talking about what happens after immediate cleanup and repairs, about what caused this to happen and what we need to do to keep this from happening again, in the future—to us.
 
If we saw the hurricanes as threats to all of us, not just Texans and Floridians, we could be talking about how important it is for all of us to be prepared for the next weather catastrophe.
 
But it’s not happening to us, just to them. So we can donate money, and we can stay glued to the Weather Channel until the most recent hurricane has passed by or weakened. Then we can return to our lives, those of us who are Americans but not affected directly by that particular hurricane, by that particular bit of weather, by that particular change in the climate.
 
And we can pretend that it’s not happening to us, just to them.
Earth ball in large body of water
Not only our island nation that is sinking: This is climate change, Nattu, Flickr, (CC BY 2.0)
0 Comments

    Author
    ​Amy Devitt

    I'm a genre-lover and language nerd who likes to write about the fascinating effects of genres (like grocery lists, blogs, and greeting cards, as well as mysteries and romances) on how we read and write and even live our lives. I also notice grammar a lot, both the "proper" kind and the fun kind, like grammar jokes.  For more, read my post on "What I Notice." I write this blog weekly to point out what I see and in hopes that you will tell me what you see, too. 

      Would you like to be notified when I publish a new post?

    Subscribe to Newsletter

    This website uses marketing and tracking technologies. Opting out of this will opt you out of all cookies, except for those needed to run the website. Note that some products may not work as well without tracking cookies.

    Opt Out of Cookies

    Archives

    June 2021
    August 2020
    July 2020
    December 2019
    August 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    January 2019
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    August 2015

    Previous Posts

    All
    7 Words Not To Say
    Acceptance Speeches
    Acceptance Speech Formula
    Ads
    Alternative Truth
    Alternative Words
    Amy Schumer
    An Academic Learns To Blog
    Apologies
    April Fools' Day
    Bad Apologies
    Bad Public Apologies
    Basketball
    Birthdays
    Bits & Pieces
    Blogging
    Boxing Day
    Business As Usual
    Busted Brackets
    Can Words Kill?
    Categories
    Children's Genres
    Choosing A Response
    Commemorating 9/11
    Commencing Graduation
    Community
    Community And Genres
    Community And Quiet
    Condolences
    Distraction Genres
    Doing Hawaiian
    Email
    Essays
    Evils Done In The Name Of Categories
    Family Reunions
    Fandom
    Father's Day
    Flu
    Funeral
    Generic Responses
    Genre
    Genre In A Scholarly Way
    Genre Reactions
    Genres Are Us
    Genres Matter
    Genre Tripping
    Good (and Bad) Apologies
    Good Sentences
    Graduation
    Greetings
    Hallmark Christmas Movies
    Halloween
    Hearing Or Trial Or Brawl
    Hi Readers!
    Holiday Greeting Cards
    Holidays
    How To Birth A Blog
    How Words Reflect & Shape Us
    Hurricanes And US
    Inaugural Address
    Indigenous Music
    Insults
    It's A Genre
    It's What You Mean
    Jet Lagged
    Labor Day
    Labor Day Genres
    Language And Genre
    Libraries
    Library Genres
    Literary Genres
    Locker Room Talk
    Making Connections
    Mass Shootings
    Meaning
    Memorial Day
    Mom's Day Cards
    Mother's Day
    Music Genres And Innovations
    Native American Musicians
    Never Forget
    New Year
    Normalizing Hatred
    Once In A Lifetime
    Patient As Medical History
    POTUS Tweets
    Preparing For Solar Eclipse
    Presidents Day
    Pronouns
    Psychology-of-genre
    Retirement
    Rhetoric-matters
    Rhetoric Still Matters
    Scenes Of Writing
    Scholarly Writing
    Solar Eclipse
    Syllabus
    Thanks Giving
    Thank You
    They Becomes Official
    Top 6 New Year's Genres
    TV Genres
    TV Genres Part 2
    Twelve Genres Of Christmas
    Twitter
    Understand Genre In Two Pictures
    Vacation
    Vacation Post Card
    Veterans Day
    Visual Genres
    Vote
    What A Syllabus Does
    What Does Alt-right Mean
    What Is A Declaration?
    What I Write About
    What Voice Recognition Software Doesn't Recognize
    When I'm Sorry Doesn't Work
    Which English Language?
    Who Is Your "They"?
    Who Is Your "We"?
    Words Can't Speak
    Words Matter
    Workshops
    WOTY Dumpster Fire
    Writing
    Writing Our Experiences
    You Know You're Old When

    RSS Feed

Copyright Amy Devitt © 2018
  • Home
  • About
  • CV and Resume
  • Publications
    • Books
    • Articles and Essays
    • Talks, Seminars, Workshops
    • Occasional Pieces
  • Genre-Colored Glasses